This week,
Barron's did a piece on the Sky high valuation on Chinese stocks. What amazes me is the similarities to the Chinese market and the Tech run up we had back in 1999. Does anyone remember that one? Apparently everyone's ulcers have healed and they are ready for another "this time it is different" market environment. Don't get me wrong, bubbles are fun, except for the popping part, but maybe that won't happen in this new Chinese economy. They have this huge booming middle class that needs as much stuff as the world can provide, right? Well, yes, but not at a growth rate consistently over 10%. Anyone remember how much fiber optic cable we needed last decade? Not near as much as we got. I believe we will see the same outcome in the Chinese market that we saw in the US tech run up in the late nineties. When will it come? That is a much more difficult question. I expect the current run up to last through the 2008 Olympics, however, I play these positions very cautiously. If I can take 20% of a move I am fine with that. I have to have the risk to reward ratio in my favor. Therefore, I only buy these Chinese/Emerging Market type securities on pull backs into support levels. Be warned, we will overshoot the valuations significantly in these securities and the US markets will feel it.......
For Andrew Barry's take in this weeks
Barron's...
IT'S TOUGH TO SAY WHEN THE CURRENT mania for Chinese stocks will end, but the potential for a significant decline is growing. China's benchmark index has shot up 109% this year, and major Chinese companies now are valued at steep premiums to their U.S. counterparts.
Warren Buffett urged investors last week to be "cautious" on Chinese stocks, adding that "we never buy stocks when we see prices soaring." Buffett recently sold Berkshire Hathaway's (ticker: BRK/A) 1.3% stake in PetroChina (PTR), China's largest company, based on its sharply rising share price. PetroChina is valued at about $440 billion, nearly double its midsummer capitalization.
The world's No. 2 company based on market value, it rapidly is closing in on ExxonMobil's (XOM) $508 billion valuation. PetroChina trades for more than 20 times estimated 2007 profits, or twice its historic price/earnings multiple, versus Exxon's P/E of 13 and P/Es of about 10 for other Western oil companies such as Chevron (CVX) and ConocoPhillips (COP). Some analysts and investors think the Chinese oil company deserves no premium to its Western peers, and is overvalued by 50% or more.......

For the complete text: China's Sky-High Valuations Don't Compute, Barron's, October 29, 2007
No comments:
Post a Comment